Cigar vs. Cigarillo: Is Size the Only Difference?

For those that are rather new to the world of cigars, the distinction between a cigarillo and a cigar might seem to be just about the size itself. While size is indeed a major factor, there are several other key differences. Here are some of the most important ones according to us: tobacco quality, construction, smoking experience, and even the way they are enjoyed. In this article, we’ll break down everything you might want to know about cigarillos vs. cigars, so you can choose the right smoke for your preferences you have.

1. Size & Shape

While size is the most obvious distinction, it's not the only factor that sets cigarillos apart from cigars.

• Cigarillo: Typically measures 3–4 inches (7–10 cm) in length with a thin diameter of roughly 16–23 ring gauge (6–9 mm). They are compact and designed for a quick & simple smoking experience.

• Cigar: Ranges from 4–8 inches (10–20 cm) in length, with a diameter that varies between 30–58 ring gauge (12–23 mm). The larger size provides a longer smoking experience.

The smaller size of a cigarillo allows it to burn faster, making it more ideal for a short break, while full-sized cigars are crafted for a slower, more relaxing experience throughout.

2. Tobacco Quality & Construction

Usually, the type and quality of tobacco used in cigarillos and cigars differs significantly.

• Cigarillo: Generally made with short filler tobacco, which consists of chopped tobacco leaves, instead of whole leaves. Many are also machine-made rather than being rolled by hand. They are also often pre-cut and does hence not require a cutter.

• Cigar: Often crafted with long filler tobacco, where whole tobacco leaves are used, providing a more complex flavor profile. Still there are definitely cigars, and and very good ones even, that are crafted with short filler tobacco as well. Premium cigars are hand-rolled and wrapped in a single high-quality, natural, leaf. Not pre-cut, requires cigar cutter.

This means that cigars typically offer a richer and more refined smoking experience, while cigarillos prioritize convenience and affordability.

3. Wrappers & Flavors

• Cigarillo: Often wrapped in homogenized tobacco leaf (a processed tobacco sheet) or a natural leaf. Some cigarillos are flavored with additives like vanilla, cherry, or rum for example. This is what you can taste on your lips instantly after placing a cigarillo in your mouth.

• Cigar: Wrapped in natural tobacco leaves that contribute significantly to the flavor. Flavored cigars exist but are far less common compared to cigarillos.

Because of their artificial flavoring, some cigarillo brands are designed to be more accessible and appealing to casual smokers, where as cigars offer a more traditional and "natural" smoking experience.

4. Smoking Experience

• Cigarillo: Often inhaled, similar to cigarettes, due to their smaller size and faster burn rate. They are meant to be smoked in 3–15 minutes.

• Cigar: Not inhaled, instead, the smoke is drawn into the mouth to savor the rich flavors. Cigars burn slower, lasting anywhere from 30 minutes to 2+ hours. If you have tried inhaling a cigar, you know it is not a pleasant experience.

If you're looking for a quick nicotine fix, a cigarillo might be the better option. However, if you want a more luxurious, slow-smoking experience, a cigar is the way to go. Both have their place in my opinion!

5. Packaging & Storage

• Cigarillo: Sold in packs of 5, 10, or 20, much like cigarettes. They don’t require humidors and are often pre-cut for convenience.

• Cigar: Sold individually or in boxes of 10, 20, or more. Cigars should be stored in a humidor to maintain their freshness and prevent drying out.

6. Cost Comparison

• Cigarillo: More affordable, typically ranging from $0.50 to $3 per stick.

• Cigar: Higher price due to the craftsmanship, with premium cigars costing anywhere from $5 to $50+ per cigar.

Final Verdict: Which One is Right for You?

If you’re looking for a quick and convenient smoke, a cigarillo is a solid choice. It’s budget-friendly, portable, and easy to smoke on the go. However, if you prefer a richer, more complex smoking experience, a premium cigar is most likely the better option for its superior craftsmanship, natural tobacco flavors, and longer burn time.

At the end of the day, it’s not just about size—cigarillos and cigars offer entirely different smoking experiences. Whether you're a casual smoker or a seasoned aficionado, there's a perfect option for every occasion.